Introductory note: I decided to break the FanFest interviews into 5 parts (one for each Athletic interviewed), even though it makes a couple of the segments pretty short, because it seems less choppy that way in that you can focus on one player at a time. My figuring is that these interviews can be a springboard not just to discuss the questions and answers transcribed below, but also to talk about that player in general.
Part I, published on Monday, featured Brandon McCarthy. Part II introduces one of the A's key off-season acquisitions, Josh Reddick, who was the centerpiece coming back in the trade which sent Andrew Bailey to the Boston Red Sox. Six bloggers, all associated with AN, participated in these interviews. This time, to avoid misquoting who asked what question, I have just put "Question" if it wasn't asked by me!

Josh Reddick profiles as the type of player who might be just adequate if he settles in RF, but who could be especially valuable if he can stick defensively in CF. So my first question to Reddick revolved around where he sees his defensive strengths and weaknesses when comparing the "corner outfield" to "center field"...
Reddick: Ideally right now I don't know where I'd want to play. I mean, I imagine with Coco coming back I'll be in RF, so that's my main focus right now. And just from looking at the dimensions of the field it seems like it'd be a bigger RF than normal but spending a whole 2-3 years in Fenway you get used to that kind of thing. So I'm going to take the approach that it's a "Fenway without a Pesky's Pole," so I don't have to deal with the messed up corner and luckily I've got a guy to my right (Coco Crisp) who can run, like I had in Boston, so hopefully he can cover a lot more ground and make it that much easier for me.
Nico: Have you played enough CF to have a sense of your comfort level there?
Reddick: Oh definitely. High school, college that's what I was, and when I first signed they transitioned me to RF for my first two minor league seasons and after those seasons I started in CF in '09 and then actually got called up and played the corners, but ever since then it's been CF and then when I get called up it was wherever they needed me, sometimes LF or RF, CF, but I feel like I'm ready to play CF no matter where it is.
Question: Are you excited about getting the chance to play every day?
Coming through a system like Boston, it's never easy to get there and stay there, especially with the way they have done things in the past - they'll go out and spend the money and not be afraid to do it. This past year, I even had a starting job when Crawford and JD Drew ended up going down and I feel like that was a huge step in my development, but it hadn't really been completed until now. (The A's) have made it clear that I'm going to be out there no matter what, no matter who's pitching - same thing with Seth (Smith), he's had that thing with LHPs where you can hit them well for a while and then all of a sudden they just somehow want to platoon you...and you get out of the practice, so hopefully I can get back into it in spring training facing LHPs more often. In my past, I‘ve never really had a problem facing them.
Question: Last year in Boston there were a lot of reports about the negative chemistry in the (clubhouse) with the "chicken ‘n beer" article...Do you think clubhouse chemistry is sort of a "chicken-egg" thing where if you win, there was good clubhouse chemistry and if you lose there isn't?
Reddick: Not necessarily. In our September fallout we were the same clubhouse we were in June and July when we were the best team in baseball. I mean, nothing changed. I think the "chicken and beer" and Tito (Francona) situation that happened, honestly I think someone opened their mouth inside the clubhouse - that's the only way it could really happen, and they needed someone to point their finger at to get somebody off their back, and I think Tito was the guy unfortunately that had to be the person with the finger pointed at him. But the clubhouse was great..."Forget yesterday, let's go get ‘em tonight." Same mindset you should have any day. Nobody had the depressed look like you expected or what you read about. We kept it pretty much the same and it just never really worked out.
Question: Since being traded to the A's, is this the first time you've met a lot of your teammates?
Yup. (laughter) This is the first I've seen him (Seth Smith) around. I've actually been in Phoenix for a couple of days so I've gotten to know a few guys. I've gotten to experience the "Dallas Braden effect"...but he's a great guy, I've met Brett Anderson. Fortunately, on the coaching staff I already knew Curt Young and Chili (Davis) - Chili was with us at AAA and Curt Young was obviously our pitching coach in Boston, but the majority I've met everybody here today and this past weekend.
Nico: Can I just ask - not qualitatively, but just in terms of style - what Chili Davis' hitting coach philosophy is, what we can expect from Chili Davis?
Reddick: Very hands-on - he likes to get involved when it's necessary. He's not going to get in your ear when you don't need him to be, and he has what every coach should have and that's an "open door" policy: Whenever you want to talk to him, he's there. I only had him for about a month and a half before I was up for my stint in "the show" but from what I learned from him he was very hands-on with me because I was struggling even when I got called up. He finds your strength and basically pounds them into your head to make sure you stay with that routine, and to make sure your mind's right for the game.
Still ahead: Seth Smith, Cliff Pennington, and Bob Melvin...
0 recs | 28 comments
can't wait to see
what kinda effect, if any, chilli has on our younger hitters. i can imagine he’d be a pretty cool coach to have around.
as some folks i knew would say it: CHILLAYYYYY!!
guessatomo - January 31, 2012
Hope Reddick works out for us
He seems to have legitimately good range on defense, I’m hoping he can eventually take over for Coco in CF. I’m a little more skeptical about his bat, he’s going to have to maintain a decent amount of power to be useful, even if he can make the transition to center.
In kind of a weird comp he reminds me a bit of Kevin Kouzmanoff. A low OBP guy who maintains his value with above average power and great defense, hopefully Reddick works out better for the A’s than Kouz did.
OkayJay81 - January 31, 2012
if/when crisp is traded away
i see grant green taking his place, i think RF is pretty much Reddick’s
guessatomo - January 31, 2012
I would think that if he can stick in CF, Reddick will be in CF
The odds of Green making it as a major league CFer are pretty low, and a good COFer is so much easier to find than a good CFer. Reddick as a RFer profiles as a good defensive player who doesn’t really hit enough, whereas if he’s a good CFer he could also profile as a good bat for the position.
Nico - January 31, 2012
good point
maybe it also depends on how green performs at AAA
guessatomo - January 31, 2012
I'm still in "wait and see" mode on Green
I’m not ready to start planning out his big league career yet. His K/BB rat is pretty ugly for someone who doesn’t have great power, I really think his ability to make it in the majors is going to depend on how good he is defensively in CF. At this point I have no idea what his outfield defense looks like, hopefully we’ll get a better idea of it when he gets some time in Sacramento
OkayJay81 - January 31, 2012
I'm not ready
to give up on green just yet
i’m a believer!
guessatomo - January 31, 2012
My concern is the combination of:
- Bad K/BB ratios
- Lack of power means everything else (OBP, contact skills, BABIP) has to be really strong
- Totally unproven in CF at a brand new position
That’s a lot of things that can go wrong where all of them have to go right.
Nico - January 31, 2012
I'm not suggesting anyone should give up on Grant Green
Just that there are enough question marks in his game that people should hold off on ordering the personalized Oakland A’s jersey with Green on the back. I think he will hit for more power than he did in AA once his wrist is at full strength and his line drive swing will generate a pretty good BABIP through out his career, but the transition to CF is going to be the key to his chances of being a useful major leaguer.
OkayJay81 - January 31, 2012
Maybe Billy is just cold
First Chili, then Coco, now maybe Coffey. Maybe he’ll get Dave “Soup” Campbell to replace Fosse.
biscuit530 - January 31, 2012
Spice, Caffeine, More Caffeine
I don’t think he’s cold, but I do think he needs some “oomph”!!!
Nico - January 31, 2012
maybe food names make them undervalued
I think there’s a chapter’s worth of material there for Moneyball II
Oaktown Shutout - February 1, 2012
I like this guy.
I hope we find a high batting average type player. I’m fully aware that OBP is what matters, but watching a legit hitter is much more exciting to watch than watching a Jack Cust, from a strictly aesthetic point of view. It’s been a while since we had a guy who put the barrel of the bat on the ball really consistently.
BWH - January 31, 2012
His swing might be pretty good for the Coliseum in terms of not suppressing slugging
I could see him having a solid BA, a “meh” OBP, and “surprisingly good slugging” by spraying a lot of doubles to all fields, and putting together a line of, say, .280/.330/.440 with 12-15 HRs, even playing half his games in Oakland. As a good CFer, that’s valuable. As a good RFer, it’s ok.
Nico - January 31, 2012
C'mon Nico...
Question: Do you have a wife? Does she Tweet? Do you have a cute dog? Does he blog?
;-)
baseballgirl - January 31, 2012
A dog, blogging. C'mon!
-Poochini
Nico - January 31, 2012
Love the series...this is great to get to know some of the new guys
baseballgirl - January 31, 2012
I love these sixclusives! Thanks to all of the interviewers for their work, and to Cindi for the transcriptions.
And I really like what Reddick said about the Boston Clubhouse. Even if there was something there, you stay on script, don’t let it keep runnng around the track.
paris7 - January 31, 2012
CIndi's doing a great job
She hopes to have the Seth Smith interview ready just as soon as she figures out the correct spelling of his name.
Nico - January 31, 2012
Great interviews...but next time we need to send at least one female representative
Maybe English Major? After all, she does work in radio.
Billy Frijoles - January 31, 2012
seconded
OaklandSi - February 1, 2012
We didn't actually choose the reps, other than me choosing Optimist Prime
(after Blez and BBG said they couldn’t make it). The others were invited by the A’s based on their representing other blogs. The A’s made all the invitations.
Nico - February 1, 2012
well then, Nico...
OaklandSi - February 1, 2012
Um, yes...?
Nico - February 1, 2012
I guess since AN had 2 official invites + the other 4 invites went to DWish and others who also happen to blog/comment on AN,
we could figure out a way to finagle in a mix of guys and gals, or at least one gal. Only because I think having that perspective helps bring more variety to the interviews.
Again, the interviews were great, a lot of these questions are ones that I wanted to know (from Seth Smith’s views on LHP, to McCarthy’s views on advanced stats/quality of contact, to the general view of Reddick and Smith coming from hitter’s parks to Oakland, etc.)…great job!
Just a suggestion to improve it in the future.
Billy Frijoles - February 1, 2012
Hey, I'm all for the mix but in this case the choice really wasn't ours
They literally invited who they wanted, with the one exception being that at the last moment I asked if I could bring someone so that I wasn’t alone (I didn’t know at the time the others would be people from AN), and I put out feelers to a couple local ANers and took the first one who said yes. So I totally agree with you in principle; it’s just that we really didn’t have an opportunity to define this particular group.
Nico - February 1, 2012
totally understood, and OP certainly deserved to go!
Billy Frijoles - February 1, 2012
It's a shame Cindi couldn't go instead, but she failed her "Highlights & Perms" midterm so...
Nico - February 1, 2012
You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Athletics Nation to post a comment.